Michael Lynche, also known as “Big Mike” is a 26 years old
former football player and personal trainer from St. Petersburg,
Florida. He is the son of former St. Petersburg Times columnist Michele
Lynche and brother to Marque Lynche Jr., who made it to Idol's
semi-finals in 2004. After Michael performed his version of “Unchained
Melody” for his Audition, it was revealed that he and his partner are
expecting a baby. Judge Kara DioGuardi called him a "singing teddy
bear".
Randy: He felt “Big Mike” was a great performer and “what a
way to start the show!
Ellen: Couldn’t find something not to love about Mike– she
thinks at some point she will be dissapointed but NOT yet!! Great
start!
Kara: Loves The Stones because they are such great performers
and that’s exactly what Mike did tonight! ‘I really liked it.
Simon: Was happy to see his confidence up but also said that
he felt the performance at times, particullary his dancing was kind of
corny. He felt the singing was good but the performance was a tiny bit
desperate (all the while the other judges loudly saying ‘no, no, no’).
Top 11: Billboard's Number One Hits
Song Choice: When A Man Loves A Woman | Play
Video
Judges Comments:
Randy:I don’t know if it was the perfect song choice, I don’t
think
it was your best vocal, but you know what I love, man? It’s the same
thing that Simon was saying about Crystal. You know who you are, you’re
this R&B soul dude. The best thing you can do is sing the ‘I
don’t
know what’ out of who you are and be theat every time you hit the
stage. That’s what you did today. I loved it.
Ellen: I did feel like it was sort of a safe choice, it was
like
driving the speed limit. You have an amazing tone, you have a great
great voice. And this woman loves that man (pointing to Lynche).
Kara: You know I love you. Technically it was really good, you
hit
all the notes. But I felt it was a bit boring and loungey at times, too
overindulgent. Too many riffs. And I lost my connection to you
performing it. I’m sorry, but you know I still love you.
Simon Cowell: I kind of know what you’re saying. It’s like you
wanted one scoop of ice cream and you got eleven. It’s almost too much.
I think if I advised you about choosing that song, no disrespect I
would have taken all this lot off the stage. I would have had just you,
piano, very simple. The truth is that this audition could have taken
place 30 years ago, 20 years ago, 10 years ago. You made it very
loungey. The good news is that you’ve got tons of charisma, you’ve got
a very very good voice, and people like you.